Why buyers get their own valuation
The asking price comes from the vendor's side. It is often set with a broker whose job is to achieve a sale, and it usually rests on adjusted earnings the vendor prepared. That does not make it wrong. It does make it one-sided.
Your report is prepared by a suitably qualified business valuer at Valuation Group, working for you rather than the vendor or the broker, on a fixed fee that does not depend on whether the deal goes ahead. We start from the records, not the information memorandum.
Engage once you can see the financial statements and before the contract becomes unconditional; ask your lawyer about due diligence and finance conditions. We value; we do not advise. What you offer stays your decision.
Testing the vendor's earnings claims
Private businesses are usually priced on earnings, so the earnings figure matters more than the multiple. Vendors present adjusted profit: reported profit plus add-backs for costs a new owner supposedly will not carry. Some are fair, some hopeful. We test each one.
- Reconcile the accounts to lodged tax returns and BAS. Figures that exist only in a spreadsheet carry less weight.
- Price the owner's labour. If the vendor works 55 hours a week on a token wage, someone has to be paid to do that work after you buy.
- Check the one-off items. A one-off repair that shows up in three of the last four years is a recurring cost.
- Look at related-party costs: rent paid to the vendor's own property trust, family wages, vehicles.
- Separate trend from spike. A strong final year just before a sale deserves questions about deferred spending and invoice timing.
- Ask what it takes to keep the earnings: equipment due for replacement, staff paid below market, marketing that quietly stopped.
What is left is maintainable earnings: what the business can reasonably earn for a new owner, year after year. The multiple then reflects risk. See business valuation methods for how the main approaches work.
Prefer to talk? 0433 475 518
Due diligence questions that change the price
Your accountant and lawyer run due diligence; we turn what they find into value. Accountants acting for a buyer can keep the financial due diligence and refer the valuation: see for accountants.
| Question | Why it affects value |
|---|---|
| How much depends on the owner? | Relationships and know-how that leave with the vendor take earnings with them. |
| Will customer contracts move to you? | Reliance on one or two customers raises risk. Contracts with assignment or change-of-control clauses may not transfer automatically. |
| What does the lease say? | Remaining term, options, rent reviews, the landlord's consent to assign and make-good all affect how secure the earnings are. |
| Which staff are key? | Losing a key technician can cut earnings. Accrued leave that may transfer with employees is a cost the price should reflect. |
| What working capital is included? | A price usually assumes a normal level of stock and debtors. If the business is handed over short, you fund the gap. |
| What needs spending soon? | Ageing vehicles, plant or software are real costs. |
| Shares or assets? | Buying shares brings the company's history with it, including its liabilities. Buying business assets generally means taking only what the contract lists. |
Earn-outs and deferred consideration, in plain terms
When buyer and vendor disagree on value, they often agree on terms instead.
- Deferred consideration: part of a fixed price is paid later, say over two years. In effect the vendor lends you part of the price.
- Earn-out: part of the price depends on performance after settlement, such as revenue or profit over one to three years. It bridges a vendor who believes in next year's growth and a buyer who wants to see it first.
Neither changes what the business is worth today; they change who carries the risk. The question is how much of the price the business supports as it stands, and how much is a bet on the future. A valuation gives you that reference point. Earn-out wording belongs with your lawyer and accountant.
Where a valuation fits with finance
Lenders generally look at whether cash flow can meet repayments and what security sits behind the loan. A business that is mostly goodwill can be harder to borrow against, one reason vendor finance and earn-outs are common in small deals.
If a lender, investor or co-buyer will see the report, tell us when you request a quote, so the addressee and who may rely on it are agreed in writing at the start.
Then test it yourself: maintainable earnings, less loan repayments and a fair wage for you. If little is left, the price may be fair and the deal still wrong for you.
Price allocation and the 2027 CGT changes
The contract usually splits the price between goodwill, equipment, stock and other assets. That split generally sets the cost of depreciating assets and forms part of your CGT cost base, and depending on the state and what is transferred, it may affect duty. A valuation can support the allocation your tax adviser and lawyer settle.
From 1 July 2027, the 50% CGT discount for Australian resident individuals and trusts (including individuals' shares of partnership gains) is generally replaced by cost base indexation for gains that build up from that date, and resident individuals pay at least 30% tax on those gains, with some exceptions. Companies can't use the 50% discount, so the transitional rule for individuals and trusts does not apply to a company's own post-1985 assets.
If you buy before then as an Australian resident individual or through a trust and still hold the business or shares at the end of 30 June 2027, you may be treated as selling just before 1 July 2027 and buying back, by default at market value. A recent arm's length price can be one piece of market evidence of that value, but market value is specific to the valuation date. Whether you need a valuation is for your tax adviser; the law also allows for a Government apportioning method, but that method is still a draft (released for consultation in August 2026, not yet final). See CGT business valuation 2027.
What you receive, fees and timing
A full valuation report on the business, shares or interest you are buying: the subject and date, the method, the earnings adjustments, the key risks and assumptions, and a reasoned conclusion of value. Guided by APES 225 Valuation Services.
The report states what we relied on and could not verify. It is not an audit or due diligence review. A calculation or limited-scope engagement is not a full valuation report; we say which you are getting before you engage us.
We charge one fixed fee of $999 + GST for a full valuation report on one business or ownership interest with annual turnover under $10 million. Larger businesses and groups are quoted in writing. The fixed fee applies once we confirm the interest, purpose, structure and records fit the fixed-fee scope. Anything outside it is quoted in writing before we start. Fixed fee, confirmed in writing before we start. No hourly billing and no surprises.
Delivery: 2 business days for turnover under $2 million, 3 business days for $2 million to $10 million. Delivery time starts once payment and all required information have been received, and pauses while we wait for answers to our questions or your signed representation letter. Deals run on the vendor's timetable as well as yours. Tell us your deadline and we will tell you on the call whether we can meet it.
Documents come only through the secure upload link on your matter, never by email. We can sign a confidentiality undertaking for the vendor first.
How it works, and what it costs
$999 + GST
Fixed fee, full valuation report
2 business days*
Turnover under $2 million
3 business days*
Turnover $2 million to $10 million
Quoted in writing
Turnover over $10 million, groups, disputes
*Delivery time starts once payment and all required information have been received, and pauses while we wait for answers to our questions or your signed representation letter. The fixed fee applies once we confirm the interest, purpose, structure and records fit the fixed-fee scope. Anything outside it is quoted in writing before we start. Fixed fee, confirmed in writing before we start. No hourly billing and no surprises. How our fee works
Questions we are often asked
When should I get a valuation if I am buying a business?
Once you can see the vendor's financial statements, tax returns and BAS, and before the contract becomes unconditional. That leaves time to renegotiate or walk away.
Is a business broker's appraisal the same as an independent valuation?
No. A broker's appraisal is prepared to market a business, usually for the vendor. It is a useful starting point, but it is not an opinion prepared for you, and it often relies on the vendor's adjusted figures.
Can you value a business when the vendor gives me very little information?
We value on evidence. If records are thin, the report says so. A vendor who cannot support their earnings is asking you to carry that risk.
Can you value shares in a company I am buying into?
Yes. We value the shares, which means looking at the company's assets and liabilities as well as its earnings. Buying part of a company raises questions of control and discounts: see valuing a minority interest.
How much does an acquisition valuation cost, and how long does it take?
We charge one fixed fee of $999 + GST for a full valuation report on one business or ownership interest with annual turnover under $10 million. Delivery is 2 business days for turnover under $2 million and 3 business days for turnover $2 million to $10 million. Delivery time starts once payment and all required information have been received, and pauses while we wait for answers to our questions or your signed representation letter. The fixed fee applies once we confirm the interest, purpose, structure and records fit the fixed-fee scope. Anything outside it is quoted in writing before we start.
What if the purchase ends in a dispute with the vendor?
A report prepared for a purchase is not a court expert report. If a dispute reaches a court or tribunal, expert evidence is a separate engagement with its own fee. Speak to your lawyer first.
Short answers
Sources
- Tax reform: reforming negative gearing and capital gains tax (QC107304), Australian Taxation Officeato.gov.au
- CGT discount, Australian Taxation Officeato.gov.au
- Treasury Laws Amendment (Tax Reform No. 1) Act 2026, Federal Register of Legislationlegislation.gov.au
- Income Tax Assessment Act 1997, Federal Register of Legislationlegislation.gov.au
- Earnout arrangements, Guide to capital gains tax, Australian Taxation Officeato.gov.au
- Deductions for depreciating assets and capital expenses, Australian Taxation Officeato.gov.au
- Market valuation for tax purposes, Australian Taxation Officeato.gov.au
Updated